You know that feeling when you stumble upon a book that refuses to let you go, one that’s a perfect mix of all the right ingredients: quirky characters, juicy plots, and a setting so vivid it feels like a second home?
Well, Reese Witherspoon’s Book Club has done it again in 2025, curating a lineup that promises just that and more. From heartfelt tales to laugh-out-loud moments, this year’s picks are like a literary rollercoaster you’ll want to ride over and over.
Whether you’re already a Reese superfan or just dipping your toes into the world of her book club gems, this list is your golden ticket. Grab your favorite mug, curl up somewhere cozy, and let’s dive deep into the five most dazzling Reese’s Book Club Picks of 2025, with a sprinkle of personal musings and a dash of that warm, bibliophile charm.
1. The Phoenix Pencil Company by Allison King
Imagine a town so small it practically hums with secrets, and a woman with a past that weighs heavier than the pencils she restores. The Phoenix Pencil Company invites you into a world where the past and present collide in dusty workshops and whispered regrets.
Allison King weaves a story about lost connections and the messy art of healing. The main character, Lily, carries the weight of family expectations and unspoken grief, and her journey through the pages feels like eavesdropping on your closest friend’s most guarded moments. Set in a charming, almost forgotten Midwestern town, this book is a love letter to small-town life, with all its hidden scars and quiet magic.
Why does this book stick with you? King’s prose is both delicate and unflinching. You’ll laugh, you’ll cringe, and most importantly, you’ll feel that rare sense of hope that grows from broken places. If you’re drawn to character-driven stories that embrace imperfection with open arms, The Phoenix Pencil Company should be your next read.
Why We Recommend It: This book sneaks up on you like a gentle breeze carrying the scent of old paper and forgotten stories. If you love novels that embrace imperfection and find beauty in the quiet, tangled moments of life, Allison King’s debut will feel like a warm hug. Perfect for readers who cherish slow-burning, character-driven tales with a heart full of nostalgia and hope.
RelatedThe Allure of Dark Romance: Why Readers Are Drawn to Dangerous Love Stories
2. Stuck Up And Stupid by Angourie Rice and Kate Rice
Here’s a treat for anyone who loves sharp wit wrapped in teenage rebellion with a splash of sibling drama. Stuck Up And Stupid is the kind of book that makes you chuckle out loud on the subway, much to the confusion of your fellow passengers.
The Rice sisters deliver a clever, snappy tale about two sisters navigating the chaos of adolescence, privilege, and all the hilarious mess that comes with it. What’s refreshing is how they don’t shy away from the awkward, embarrassing parts of growing up; instead, they lean into them, making every cringeworthy moment utterly relatable.
The setting, a bubble of suburban high school antics, is bursting with energy and a not-so-subtle critique of social hierarchies. It’s the perfect palate cleanser after heavier reads, offering a breezy but sharp exploration of family ties and identity. If you crave humor that’s honest and sharp, this duo’s debut will hit all the right notes.
Why We Recommend It: Honestly, this one’s a riot. If you’ve ever survived (or are surviving) the chaos of family drama and teenage awkwardness, the Rice sisters nail it with their sharp humor and unfiltered honesty. It’s like eavesdropping on the funniest, most brutally honest sibling squabbles, so if you’re into contemporary YA with a sassy, no-filter voice, this is your jam.
Enjoying this article?
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter3. Great Big Beautiful Life by Emily Henry
If you haven’t yet succumbed to Emily Henry’s charm with People We Meet on Vacation, Great Big Beautiful Life might just be the book that finally gets you. It’s a love story, yes, but one that’s layered, messy, and wonderfully human.
Set against the backdrop of a road trip that’s as much about escaping the past as it is about chasing dreams, Henry introduces us to characters bursting with flaws and fierce hopes. The prose sparkles with her signature blend of humor and heartache, painting relationships that feel raw and real.
This book stands out because it refuses to settle for neat resolutions. Instead, it embraces the beautiful chaos of life’s “what-ifs” and “maybe laters”, inviting readers to savor the uncertainty. If you adore stories that feel like warm conversations with your wisest friend, Great Big Beautiful Life is your go-to.
Why We Recommend It: Emily Henry’s magic is in making you feel every messy, thrilling heartbeat of life. This isn’t your typical love story; it’s a celebration of all the messy edges we try to hide. If you adore swoony romances sprinkled with genuine emotional depth and characters that stay with you long after closing the book, dive right in.
Related10 Most Spicy Romance Books Coming Out In 2025
4. All That Life Can Afford by Emily Everett
Prepare to have your heart squeezed, in the best way possible. All That Life Can Afford is a haunting exploration of resilience, love, and the invisible battles we all fight.
Emily Everett crafts a narrative that feels intimate and expansive at once, tracing a woman’s journey through grief and the fragile hope that blooms in its aftermath. The characters are etched with such care you almost want to reach out and hold them, and the setting, a blend of familiar places touched by loss, becomes a silent companion throughout.
This pick shines because of its emotional honesty and the graceful way it handles tough themes without ever losing sight of light. It’s perfect for readers who seek stories that don’t shy away from life’s shadows but still find a way to celebrate the small, fierce joys. A beautiful, bittersweet read that stays with you long after the last page.
Why We Recommend It: This is a tender, haunting gem for anyone who knows what it means to carry loss and still find light. Emily Everett doesn’t sugarcoat grief but shows how it’s possible to bloom anyway, a beautiful reminder that healing isn’t linear. If you want a story that’s raw yet quietly uplifting, this one will wrap around you like a soft blanket.
Related10 Binge-Worthy Historical Fiction Books Coming Out In March You Can’t Miss
5. Heiress Takes All by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka
Last but definitely not least, Heiress Takes All brings a fresh twist to the romantic comedy genre with a story that’s as clever as it is heartfelt.
Wibberley and Siegemund-Broka deliver a tale full of sharp banter, unexpected friendships, and a romance that feels both electric and grounded. The protagonists’ chemistry leaps off the page, fueled by witty dialogue and a plot that keeps you guessing, all wrapped in a glamorous, high-stakes setting that contrasts beautifully with the characters’ vulnerabilities.
What I loved most? How the book balances humor with sincere moments of self-discovery, proving that love stories can be smart without losing their warmth. If you crave a rom-com with bite and heart, this one’s a knockout.
Why We Recommend It: I’m all for a romance that’s smart, funny, and a little bit daring, and this one delivers on all fronts. The banter alone is worth the read, but what really stands out is the genuine heart beneath all the glam. If you crave rom-coms that don’t just make you swoon but also make you think, this book is a sparkling gem for your shelf.
Reese’s 2025 Book Club Picks don’t just entertain, they invite you to feel deeply, laugh freely, and rethink what stories can do. From small-town secrets to sparkling romance, each title on this list is a gateway to a world you won’t want to leave.
So, whether you’re looking for your next binge-worthy read or a heartfelt companion for a quiet evening, these five books have got your back. Grab one (or all), and let yourself be swept away, because in the end, isn’t that what great stories are all about?
