One Day (2024): A Discussion And Comparison

Table of Contents

We begin discussing the 2024 Netflix miniseries adaptation of the novel One Day by David Nicholls. The 14-episode series faithfully adapts the 2009 book, which was previously made into a 2011 film starring Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess. This new adaptation stars Ambika Maud as Emma Morley and Leah Woodall as Dexter Mayhew in the lead roles.

One Day Summary

one-day-main-characters — Courtesy of Netflix

The premise follows Emma and Dexter, introduced as students at the University of Edinburgh, who meet on July 15th, 1988 – their college graduation day. A spark occurs between the opposites – Emma is driven and aspires to be a writer, while Dexter is privileged yet aimless. After sharing an intimate night together, their lives reconnect annually on that same date, July 15th.

In the early episodes, we see their lives diverge as Emma struggles as a reluctant Mexican restaurant worker while failing to publish her writing. Meanwhile, Dexter lazily teaches English abroad fueled by family money before finding a minor celebrity as a loud, obnoxious TV personality. Their friendship persists despite romantic tensions and compatibility issues.

As the years progress, Emma finally gets her start as a novelist living in Paris, though a romantic reconciliation with Dexter leads nowhere when he’s newly married to another woman after getting her pregnant. Emma returns to London and begins a relationship with aspiring comedian Ian, which ends due to her lingering feelings for Dexter resurfacing.

Dexter’s life is a roller coaster – he has a daughter with his first wife Sylvie but their marriage crumbles due to his immaturity and her infidelity. Finally, after over a decade of push-and-pull, Emma and Dexter commit to one another as a couple in the late 90s. They marry and he opens a successful cafe bakery with her support and his inheritance after his mother’s passing.

one-day-dex-and-girlfriend — Courtesy of Netflix

Tragically, on the 15th anniversary of their fateful first meeting in 2002, Emma dies suddenly in a biking accident. This shatters Dexter, who regresses into destructive alcoholism and substance abuse, pushing away his daughter and friends in his all-consuming grief over the years.

The miniseries skips through the aftermath – Dexter’s hardships caring for his cafe alone, his loved ones’ attempts to support him through recovery’s ups and downs, and glimmers of acceptance as he forms new bonds with his aging father. In heartbreaking final scenes, a more clear-eyed Dexter returns to Edinburgh to reminisce at the old sites of his memories with Emma.

Final Thoughts

While immensely sad overall, the adaptation concludes on a wistful note of hope that Dexter can move forward while cherishing Emma’s lasting impact on his life’s journey. We discuss how the series deftly captures the melancholic yet uplifting atmosphere of Nicholls’ original novel through its excellent performances and adherence to the source material’s writing thanks to the author’s direct involvement.

Both the writing and performances are standouts in the miniseries, with Maud and Woodall’s chemistry a high point. Though Dex and Em’s relationship has its early fumbles, their differences seem to be what draws them together. It’s through small interactions between them that the audience experiences the excitement of the will-they-won’t-they element of the story.

We encourage listeners to share any particular lesser-known cultural myths, folktales, or areas of the world’s vast repository of oral traditions they would love to see explored more as the basis for engaging retellings or adaptations across novels, films, TV, and other modern mediums. The possibilities for innovatively reviving these timeless tales for a new generation of diverse readers and fans are vast.

Enjoying this episode? Be sure to check out all of our coverage of the genre over at https://fully-booked.ca/. We’re a listener-supported podcast! Please consider pledging and helping Fully Booked to grow our library over at https://ko-fi.com/fullybooked, or by leaving us a 5-star rating and review wherever you’re listening. Thanks, bookworms, and don’t forget to keep on reading!